2007 In-Season Trades
Date |
Team |
Gets |
Team |
Gets |
Mar. 18
|
Opening Day
|
May 8
|
SB
|
1B Prince
Fielder
|
VAN |
SP Chris
Carpenter
|
May 24
|
NWK
|
RP Rafael
Soriano
'08 2nd Round
|
PHI |
SS Jimmy
Rollins
RP Brandon Lyon
|
June 10
|
DC
|
RP Chris
Ray
3B Ryan Zimmerman
1B Derrek Lee
|
LV |
OF Matt
Holliday
3B Alex Gordon
'08 1st
Round
|
June 12
|
LV
|
'08 2nd
Round
|
SAR |
SP Daisuke
Matsuzaka
|
June 27
|
MAR
|
SP Woody
Williams
|
VAN |
'08 8th
Round
|
June 29
|
NJ
|
SP Jorge
Sosa |
PHI |
C A.J.
Pierzynski
|
July 12
|
HBK
|
1B/OF Greg
Norton
RP Brandon League
|
SB |
RP Adam
Wainwright
|
July 14
|
MAR
|
RP B.J.
Ryan |
SAR |
'08 5th
Round
|
July 15
|
PHI
|
OF J.D.
Drew |
VAN |
'08 5th
Round
'09 5th Round
|
July 15
|
HBK
|
RP Wes
Littleton |
VAN |
'08 8th
Round
|
July 15
|
Trade Deadline
|
The trade deadline has come and gone, and
no more trades can be made until after this year's World Series. Let's
take a look back and review the year in trades.
There were a total of 22 trades made this
season (12 in the off-season, 10 during the seaon). In terms of trades
made, it was the most since 1999, when there were 33 trades made; in
fact, since 1996, the earliest period for which we have data, this
season ranks behind only '99 and '98 (26 trades). But don't get too
excited about this being the third-busiest season for trades, as there
were 21 trades made in '06 and also in '02.
This year's 22 trades involved 36 players
and 21
picks, a total of 57 "commodities." That's actually a relatively low
number considering the number of trades made; even though there was one
fewer trade made last year, there were 74 commodities exchanged (45
players, 29 picks). There were 57 commodities dealt in 19 trades in '05
(26 players, 31 picks), 46 in 13 trades in '04 (34 players, 12 picks)
and 54 in 16 trades in '03 (36 players, 18 picks). The biggest year in
terms of commodities that we know of (since '96) was '99, when there
were 121 commodities (83 players, 38 picks) in 33 trades.
This year there were 12 off-season trades
and 10 in-season trades. We've been splitting trades by
in-season/off-season since '02, and this ranks as the busiest
off-season we have on record, beating '05 by a single off-season trade.
In terms of in-season trades, it ranks third, behind '06 (13) and '02
(12).
The most active teams in terms of trades
were
the Las Vegas Rat Pack, Marietta
Mighty Men and Vancouver Iron Fist, who
each made 7 deals. The Philadelphia
Endzone Animals were right behind them with 6 deals, followed by
the Sardine City Straphangers (4), then D.C. Bushslappers (3) and Hoboken
Cutters (3), then the Newark Sugar Bears
(2) and South
Boston Gang (2). The Arkansas Golden Falcons, Honolulu Sharks and New
Jersey Team Buddah each made 1 deal. The only teams not to make any
deals were the Carolina
Mudcats and the Hillsborough Hired Hitmen.
Five teams partenered up twice: Las Vegas
and D.C., Philly and Vancouver, Marietta and Vancouver, Marietta and
Sardine City, and Las Vegas and Sardine City. No other teams made more
than one trade with each other.
Now let's look at the 10 in-season trades
in detail. (To
read all about this year's 12 off-season
trades, check out our previous edition of Trade Talk.)
We broke down the 10 in-season trades into
three
groups:
The three trades that were "win-wins," that left both teams relatively
happy;
the
four deals that one team appeared to come out ahead on; and the three
deals that
we just aren't sure yet.
Just about every trade is proposed as a
"win-win" deal -- you might secretly think you're ripping the guy off,
but you still have to pitch it as a trade that helps both teams. And
sometimes, as in the case of the following three trades, they really do
turn out to be an improvement for both teams.
For example, consider the first trade of
the regular season -- a May 8 deal between Vancouver and South Boston.
On paper, it just might be the classic example of a "win-win" trade --
that is, unless it turns out to be the continuation of the most storied
curse in DMBL history!
The Iron Fist, in
need of a starting pitcher, gave up 23-year-old first baseman Prince Fielder, while the Gang, looking toward
next year, swapped 32-year-old starting pitcher Chris
Carpenter. Fielder was one of the most coveted batting
prospects in baseball -- he'd been drafted as a prospect in 2004 and
2005, but not retained. Then the Iron Fist took him in the 3rd Round
(#40 overall) of the '06 draft as an ineligible prospect and protected
him this off-season. Fielder wasn't expected to do much this year as a
rookie (MLB '06: .271 BA, .347 OBP,
.483 SLG) but no one expected him to be this bad (.183 BA, .543
OPS in 71 AB). He also was buried in the depth chart behind David Ortiz and Conor Jackson.
So while Fielder was regarded as a promising future slugger, he was
deemed an expendable commodity to the Iron Fist front office. But
still, at the time of the deal, some wondered if he was too much to
give up in exchange for what could be just one year from Carpenter. (At
the time of the deal, it looked like he would
be ineligible for the 2008 season -- he was shut down after just one
'07 MLB start with an elbow injury; now he's rehabbing and just might
qualify for next season.) In any event, this clearly was a deal the
Iron Fist made
for today, not tomorrow, as they were in the thick of the division
race. Carpenter hadn't had a great start with South Boston (3-4, 5.20
ERA, 13.8 R/9, .333 QS%), but there was every indication he could pitch
better than that (MLB '06: 3.09 ERA,
10.0 R/9).
After the deal, Fielder has looked much more comfortable in
South Boston (.245, .741 OPS in 220 AB), where he's getting a chance to
play just about every day and is undoubtedly the team's first baseman
of the present and future, and no doubt will contribute even more next
season (MLB '07: .284 BA, .996 OPS,
29 HR in 324 AB). Meanwhile, just as expected, Carpenter has
pitched a lot better for the
Fisters, going 7-3 with a 4.76 ERA, 11.9 R/9 and .538 QS%. Those
numbers are even more impressive when you consider who the Fisters
would've had to use in the rotation if they hadn't acquired Carpenter;
every other starter, other than Greg Maddux
and Jake Peavy, has ERAs at 5.80 and R/9s at
13.6 or higher, and only Carpenter and Maddux have better than a .500
QS%.
But the oddest thing about this trade is
that the Fisters
were
31-20 and in 3rd place overall, just 3 games behind Philly for
the division lead; now they're 59-59 and in 8th place, 2½ games
behind Honolulu for the final playoff berth. How could giving up a
player
that
didn't contribute at all in exchange for a top starting pitcher result
in
such a rapid fall in the standings?
It Vancouver is indeed cursed for the rest
of its existence, then undoubtedly they lost in this deal. But if
that's not the case, this deal appears to be fairly even so far: The
Gang got a young slugger, but the Iron Fist didn't need him. They got
back a starter who, despite the team's overall performance, has pitched
very well so far. The fact that Carpenter could conceivably contribute
to their 2008 campaign also helps even things out. So let's call this
one a win-win.
Another trade that left both sides happy --
kind'a -- was struck on the day before the deadline. The Straphangers, after prolonged negotiations
with multiple teams, finally pulled off the long-awaited trade of
closer B.J. Ryan. The 31-year-old lefty has
incredible stuff (MLB '06: 1.37 ERA,
0.86 WHIP) and had a 3.35 ERA, 11.9 R/9 and 35 K in 37.2 IP for
the Straphangers this year, but is expected to be ineligible next
season. That gives him limited value to 13th-place Sardine City. But
the 5th overall pick in this year's Dispersal Draft team had plenty of suitors among the
playoff teams. The Hangmen are rumored to have considered and rejected
several offers in the hope of driving up the bidding, waiting until the
second-to-last day to finally accept Marietta's 5th
Round draft pick.
After the deal, both sides were wondering
if it was a fair one -- usually a good sign that it was an even swap.
Ryan has pitched brilliantly in two appearances so far with the Mites
(0 R, 0 H, 0 BB, 6 K in 4.0 IP), but some wonder why the front office
didn't use that pick to go get a starting pitcher, instead of adding
another reliever to a bullpen that already features DMBL legends Mariano Rivera and Trevor
Hoffman. There's also the question if the Mites could have pried
Ryan away for less, or maybe convinced the Sardine City front office to
throw in another player or a late pick. At the same time, some sources
inside the Sardine City front office had earlier said they'd accept
nothing less than a 4th Round pick for Ryan, and instead they settled
for one of the last picks of the 5th Round. Some Straphanger fans were
annoyed that Ryan was traded at all, saying he should have been
squirreled away for 2009, as South Boston did this year (and last) with
Eric Gagne.
Well, any trade that is second-guessed by
that many people on either side must be a fair one. What remains to be
seen if it's a double-win or a double-loss. For the moment, we'll just call it a draw.
The final trade of the 2007 regular season
was consummated moments before the trade deadline at midnight, as the
Iron Fist swapped reliever Wes Littleton
to the Cutters for an 8th Round
draft pick. Littleton, a 24-year-old rookie taken in the 5th
Round (#69
overall) of this year's draft, was expected to be a key member of the
Iron Fist bullpen this year (MLB '06: 1.73 ERA, 0.99 WHIP in 36.3
IP). But he proved to be overmatched in the DMBL (4.84 ERA, 13.6
R/9, 29 BB, 30 K in 61.1 IP), particularly against left-handed batters
(.364, 1.116 OPS). He also appeared to be of dubious value for next
season (MLB '07: 4.19 ERA, 1.14 WHIP in 11 G; now in Triple-A).
But despite Littleton's ugly numbers with the Iron Fist, the Cutters
badly needed a reliever -- in fact, his 4.84 ERA with Vancouver would
be second-best in the Hoboken bullpen, just behind only Juan Rincon (4.82 ERA)!
Littleton was nearly perfect in his
only appearance so far with the Cutters (0 R, 1 H, 0 BB, 2 K in 1.1
IP), but it remains to be seen if he reverts to his old form. And even
if he does, he'd still be an improvement over the guy he replaced in
the 'pen, Braden Looper (4.92 ERA,
16.6 R/9). So it appears the Cutters did a good job in acquiring
Littleton for an 8th Round pick, even if he doesn't come close to their
protected list. As for the Vancouver, an 8th Round pick seems fair
compensation for a guy who was being routinely booed by Iron Fist fans.
This swap likely won't go down in the history books as an all-time
great trade, but at the moment it looks like a very
minor win for each team.
Then there are those trades that
we're
confident we already know who won and who lost. Yes, in a year's time
we may feel differently, but for right now, these four trades appear to
have
a clear winner and a clear loser.
The Bushslappers are in just their
second
season, but they've already
made a number of headline deals with the Rat Pack. Last year, they
exchanged 10 players and eight picks in three deals; this year, it was
seven players and two picks in two deals. The two have exchanged such
notable players as Carlos Beltran, Alfonso Soriano and Carl
Crawford. Last year, the deals were mostly sending veteran players
to Las Vegas for its playoff run, with younger players and prospects
heading to D.C. as it was being built as a first-year franchise;
this
year, the deals seem to be swinging in the opposite direction as Las
Vegas is likely to finish with the league's worst record while the
Bushslappers are in the thick of the playoff hunt. In an example of
such a trade, the Bushslappers traded away outfielder Matt Holliday, prospect Alex
Gordon and their 1st Round draft pick, and
got back from Las Vegas reliever Chris Ray,
first baseman Derrek Lee and third baseman Ryan Zimmerman.
It was obvious to see why Vegas made
this
deal. Ray, while just 25
years old and having a very good season (3.66 ERA, 9.4 R/9, 15 BB, 42 K
in 46.2 IP), doesn't look like a keeper for next year (MLB '07: 4.54 ERA, 1.22 WHIP), and
at this point that's the only thing that matters to the rebuilding Rat
Pack. Lee, an ineligible 31-year-old first baseman,
looks like he will be a
keeper next season (MLB '07: .335,
.915 OPS in 319 AB) but the Rat Pack is set at first base with Mark Teixeira. And Zimmerman, regarded as a top
prospect last year, was having a fine season (.285, .806 OPS, 11 HR, 43
RBI in 316 AB for Las Vegas) but didn't look like a keeper (MLB '07: .256, .740 OPS) and was
buried in the depth chart behind Chone Figgins
and Edwin Encarnacion. All three of the
players Vegas sent to D.C. could be considered expendable for both this
year and next.
As for the Bushslappers, there was no
blaming them for wanting to ship off Gordon, a 23-year-old third
baseman regarded by some as the best prospect in baseball. They'd taken
Gordon this year with the 23rd overall pick, but he was having trouble
living up to those lofty expectations in the D.C. farm system (MLB '07: .200 BA, .600 OPS at the time of
the deal). It seemed like a fair deal to convert him into
Zimmerman, who had the benefit of being eligible for this season and
was in fact seven months younger than Gordon anyway. As for Holliday,
he was struggling mightily in D.C. (.218, .692 OPS in 335 AB), and
there were whispers that the outfielder -- one of the last hold-overs
from the old Columbia Rattlesnakes -- had the "taint" of that cursed
franchise hanging around him. But still, Holliday is just 27 years old
and looks very much like he will be a keeper for next season (MLB '07: .339, .964 OPS in 366 AB).
However, one could make an argument that Lee and Holliday are
comparable keepers for next season, even though Lee is four years
older, ineligible for this season, and plays the less demanding
defensive position.
But if
Gordon is cancelled out by Zimmerman and Holliday by Lee, that leaves
the trade of Ray for a 1st round pick -- a deal few owners would regard
as an even exchange. Making the deal all the worse for the Bushslappers
is
that Ray has been a complete disaster (0-3, 8 ER, 11 H, 7 BB, 3 HR in
8.1 IP). So even if the rest of the deal evens out -- Gordon for
Zimmerman, Holliday for Lee -- the deal still boils down to the
Bushslappers giving up a 1st
Round pick for a reliever who has already cost them at least three
games, and at this point doesn't look like a keeper for next season.
When you also consider that Ray was worthless to Vegas anyway, this
deal must be regarded as a win for the Rat Pack.
That was the regular season's biggest
trade, with six commodities exchanged (five players, one pick); next
up, we'll review the second-biggest, the May 24 swap between Newark and
Philly that saw three players and a pick change hands.
Philly has had a real problem at
shortstop
this season: An
amazing nine different players have had at least one game at short,
including five guys who have played at least five games there. In fact,
the franchise has been looking for an answer shortstop since they
traded away Rafael Furcal in 2005. The Sugar
Bears, on the other hand, had too many guys for the position -- the
original plan was to play Jimmy Rollins at
short and use Carlos Guillen as the designated
hitter, but then Mark Teahen came out of
nowhere to claim the third base job, pushing Chipper
Jones to DH, Guillen to SS and Rollins to the bench. Though he got
in some time as a defensive replacement and pinch runner (and went
5-for-15 as a pinch hitter), the 28-year-old switch-hitter was
overqualified (and overpaid) as a utility player. So the Sugar Bears
were willing to sell; the question was, how much were the Endzone
Animals willing to pay? The two owners haggled for about a month before
finally coming up with a deal that sent Rollins and reliever Brandon Lyon down the Turnpike to Philly in
exchange for reliever Rafael Soriano and a 2nd Round draft pick.
Rollins immediately took over as the
Animals'
shortstop, and so far the results have been mixed. He's hitting an
unimpressive .258, compared to the .287 BA posted by the guy he
replaced, David Eckstein (although Rollins's OPS is 60 points higher).
And while Rollins had 4 stolen bases to Eckstein's 2,
Rollins also has been caught 5 times. J-Roll also been a
mixed blessing with the glove, ranking first in the league in fielding
percentage (.990) but near the bottom of the pack in total chances per
game (3.8). In fact, while some thought Rollins's real value over
Eckstein would come in the field, the two posted fairly similar
numbers defensively. Considering how pumped the Endzone Animal fans
were to get him, Rollins has to be considered a disappointment so far.
On the other hand,
Rollins is still only 28 years old, and some expect he'll be a key
member of this team come next year (MLB
'07: .286, .847 OPS, 16 HR, 15 SB in 71 G). He better be, as
Rollins is the only thing Philly has to show from this deal; they cut
Lyon a few weeks after making the deal.
You could also look at this deal as
addition by subtraction in terms of the Philly bullpen -- Soriano was a
disaster for them over the first quarter of the season (6.99 ERA, 15.6
R/9 in 28.1 IP). He's been only slightly better in Newark (6.52
ERA, 14.9 R/9 in 9.2 IP), and the Sugar Bears recently put him on the
D.L. after he finally admitted to team trainers that his arm just
hasn't felt right since spring training. The Sugar Bears can afford to
take it easy with him down the stretch this year, but still hope the
27-year-old will factor into their plans for next year (MLB '07: 2.79 ERA, 0.83 WHIP in 38.2 IP).
And of course Newark's GM still has tucked away in his pocket that 2nd
Round pick. It's likely to be near the end of the round, but the Sugar
Bears certainly are familiar with finding value there. Rollins has
provided more value this season than Soriano, and both are likely
keepers; however, the 2nd Round pick makes this one a win for the Sugar Bears.
That trade got all kinds of
publicity, but
a month later the Endzone Animals made a much quieter swap, this time
with Team Buddah. The Endzone Animals would have one of the league's
best catchers in David Ross, provided all
pitchers were left-handed (.317 BA, 1.390 OPS vs LHP; .176, .509 vs
RHP). He obviously needed to be platooned, but no one could handle the
other half of the job as the team tried Javier
Valentin (.250, .589), Jason Varitek
(.100, .200) and Rod Barajas
(.105, .255). Meanwhile, New Jersey had an awesome platoon going at
catcher, with Mike Piazza (.372, 1.055 vs LHP)
and A.J. Pierzynski
(.383, .994 vs RHP) combining to give the team some of the league's
best production at backstop. But it was all for naught as neither
veteran looked like a keeper and the team was well out of playoff
contention. So the Animals picked up A.J. to pair with Ross, sending
swingman Jorge Sosa to the Buddahs.
Unfortunately, Pierzynski appears to have left his bat in New Jersey,
as he's looked just as bad as the previous partners (.214, .517 in 28
AB). There's still time for him to pick it up, of course; either way,
it's likely to be his last season in Philly (MLB '07: .254 BA, .684 OPS). Sosa, on the other hand, while being essentially
useless in the DMBL this year (MLB
'06: 5.42 ERA, 1.51 WHIP), looks like a keeper for next year (MLB '07: 3.84 ERA, 1.21 WHIP).
Now, it's possible Sosa will implode over the second half and not be
worth keeping; or even that he will be protected but pitch as poorly as
he did last year with Phoenix and Hoboken (1-6, 4.52 ERA in 11 games).
And it's also still possible Pierzynski will regain the stroke he had
in Jersey and finally give Ross a worthy platoon partner. But at this
moment in time, this trade has to be regarded as a win for Team Buddah.
Another trade that wasn't exactly a
headliner was the June 27 swap between Marietta and Vancouver. The
Mighty Men had
been looking for a fifth starter essentially all season, having tried Gil Meche (2-5, 6.96 ERA, 15.9 R/9), Mark Hendrickson (1-2, 8.31 ERA, 23.9 R/9), Jeff Suppan (0-3, 8.38 ERA, 16.8 R/9) and Brett Tomko
(0-2, 9.19 ERA, 20.1 R/9). So the front office went
looking for outside help. Readily available was Vancouver's Woody Williams. The 40-year-old right-hander has had a
journeyman DMBL career -- he's
played for seven teams in nine years -- and over that span has gone
41-62 with a 5.10 ERA. In fact, he's had a winning record just once
(14-5 with Newark in '01), although his 8-18 mark in '03 with Brooklyn
had a lot more to do with his lack of run support (3.99 ERA, 1.24
WHIP). This season, it was more struggles for Woody -- despite the fact
that the Iron Fist had protected him this off-season, he had been
demoted to Triple-A after going 0-2 with a 10.66 ERA and 19.9 R/9 in
his first three starts for the Iron Fist. But the Mighty Men figured he
still had something left (MLB '06:
3.65 ERA, 1.29 WHIP), and after all, he couldn't be
worse than their other options, right? So the Mites gave up an 8th Round
draft pick and slotted Williams into their rotation. In his first three
starts for his new team, Williams was awful (0-1, 16 ER, 22 H, 4 BB, 2
K in 10.1 IP). But just as it seemed Marietta was also going to give up
on Woody, he threw a shutout
against the Straphangers (0 R, 4 H, 1 BB,
7 K) for his first win of the season. Granted, Sardine City has by far
the worst offense in baseball, but the Mighty Men can only hope he can
build on this performance. But the bottom line is even after the
shutout, Woody is still 1-1 with a 7.45 ERA and 15.4 R/9 for the Mighty
Men, numbers not much better than the ones that sent Meche to Triple-A
and Hendrickson, Suppan and Tomko to the waiver wire. He's also not
going to be worth keeping next year
(MLB '07: 5.37 ERA, 1.42 WHIP).
We're
a little reluctant to say anyone won this trade as an 8th Round pick
isn't much compensation for a guy who the Iron Fist thought was worth
protecting just five months ago, but something's better than nothing.
Assuming Williams's performance against the Straphangers says more
about Sardine City's offense than it does about Woody, we're going to
call this one a slight win for the Iron Fist.
Hey, this prognostication stuff ain't
easy.
It's just too soon to tell who won the following three trades.
First we'll look at the Trade
Deadline Day
deal between Vancouver and Philadelphia. After their miserable June
swoon in which they dropped five places in the standings, the Iron Fist
were in that no man's land every owner dreads -- not good enough
to count on reaching the post-season, but not bad enough to get a good
lottery pick, either. With the trade deadline looming, owner Yaro Zajac had to decide whether it was time
to add another player to help with this year's team, or start unloading
some non-keepers with an eye toward next year. On the surface, it would
appear the first of the two deals the team made Sunday were in
rebuilding mode. But a closer look reveals that the Iron Fist may be
attempting to achieve addition through subtraction.
J.D. Drew
was one of the most coveted prospects in baseball when Philly took him
with the 4th overall pick of the 1999 draft -- the highest any
ineligible player has ever been selected. He then had five so-so
seasons with the Endzone
Animals. But in 2005, he had a monster season, setting career highs in
just about
everything (.322, .995 OPS, 34 HR, 126 R, 98 RBI). This didn't exactly
endear him to Philly fans, who felt he'd finally delivered only because
it was a "walk year." Sure enough, Drew left the Endzone Animals at
the end of that season as the Iron Fist selected him with the 12th
overall pick of the 2006 draft. To the chagrin of Philly fans, he then
had
an even better year (.320,
1.059 OPS, 40 HR, 107 R, 102 RBI), despite missing about 40 games due
to various aches and pains.
The Iron Fist brought him as a keeper
for
'07 hoping to see more of the same, but Drew tailed off badly this
year, hitting just .239 (.720 OPS) in 297 ABs. In fact, Drew had
recently been riding the pine behind youngsters Andre Ethier and Curtis
Granderson. Yet he still remained an intriguing option for
teams looking for some left-handed pop (MLB '06: .296, .946 OPS vs
RHP). And that's exactly what the Endzone Animals needed, after
finding no help from Magglio Ordonez
(.242, .677 OPS vs RHP), Michael Cuddyer
(.227, .573 OPS vs RHP), Trot Nixon
(1-for-11) or Jeff DaVanon
(0-for-6). There also is the sentimentality of Drew
returning to his
original team -- although he's not exactly a fan favorite in some
circles. So the Iron Fist had every reason to get rid of Drew, and the
Endzone Animals had every reason to acquire him. But for how much? In
the end, Philly agreed to give up a 5th Round pick this year and a 5th
Round pick next year.
The trade has been equally praised
and
condemned by fans
of either team. Vancouver was happy to get anything for a guy they
weren't using anyway and weren't likely to protect; on the other hand,
some Iron Fist fans have complained that a pair of 5th Round picks
isn't enough compensation for a keeper-list player who was a first
round pick just one year ago.
At the same time, some Philly fans say their team overpaid for a guy
who had already lost his job in Vancouver.
So who won? We dunno. By
all indications Drew is a
better hitter than he has looked so far this season, and could be a
tremendous help to the Endzone Animals in the post-season. There's also
still
the possibility that the 31-year-old will wind up a keeper for the
Animals (MLB '07: .260, .763 OPS overall, but .308, .906 since June
1). If Drew
has a monster fourth quarter and winds up on Philly's protected list,
the Endzone Animals made out like bandits. On the other hand, if he
continues to hit the way he did in Vancouver and isn't worth
keeping next year, it's a slam dunk win for Vancouver. If the
results are somewhere in between, it could wind up being a wash,
depending on which players the Iron Fist get with the Philly picks.
We'll
have to say right now that this trade is too close
to call.
Another deal that the jury is still
out is
the June 12 swap between the Rat Pack and the Straphangers. If you
think it's rare to see a trade between the two teams at the top of the
standings, consider this exchange between the two teams battling it
out for the league's worst record! Both were in rebuilding mode, but
each had its own method. The Rats wanted to make some trades for
players for next year, but they were limited in what they could do as
they already had the maximum five ineligible players on the roster.
Meanwhile, the Hangmen were interested in adding to their protected
list a starting pitcher. So the two teams
came to an agreement, with the Rats sending Daisuke
Matsuzaka to Sardine City in exchange for Rats' 2nd Round draft pick. (The Straphangers
inherited Las Vegas's 2nd Round pick in the '08 draft from the Westwood
Deductions, who obtained it as part of the July 13, 2006, deal that
sent Derrek Lee to the Rats.)
Curiously, in the '07
draft, Dice-K had been a 3rd Round pick (#37 overall), but now without
throwing a pitch in the DMBL his value had been risen by about 20
spots -- even his numbers at the time weren't anywhere close to the
pre-season hype (MLB '07: 7-5, 4.52
ERA,
1.31 WHIP at the time of the deal). But perhaps the Hangmen had
actually "bought low" on Matsuzaka, as he's been a
lot more impressive recently (4-1,
2.70 ERA,
1.17 WHIP since the deal was made; 11-6, 3.94 ERA, 1.27 WHIP overall).
Based on his numbers at the time of the deal, or even his overall
numbers now, it appears the Strappers overpaid, as there generally are
starting pitchers with numbers better than a 4.00 ERA/1.30 WHIP at the
top of the second round. But if Dice-K continues to pitch at his more
recent level of production -- and proves to be the top-shelf ace
starter he was in Japan -- they got a bargain. At this point, it's just
too soon to tell who
won this one.
The Cutters bolstered their
bullpen and their lineup with the first deal of the final week before
the deadline. On July 12th,
they sent struggling rookie Adam Wainwright
to South Boston in exchange for RP Brandon
League and 1B/OF Greg Norton.
The 25-year-old Wainwright was a highly prized young pitcher when he
was drafted in the 4th round (#48 overall) of this year's draft, but
he'd been terrible so far, posting an 8.77 ERA and 15.8 R/9 (and a
ridiculous .943 OPS allowed, mostly due to his 19 HRs in just 66.2 IP).
The two players the Gang gave up to
get Wainwright were both having excellent campaigns. League was 8-2
with 3 saves and 15 holds (2.24 ERA, 10.7 R/9) as the team's top set-up
man, while Norton, the team's DH against righties, was hitting .309
with an .850 OPS overall, and an even more impressive .325/.902 vs RHP.
League, 24, was expected to be a good reliever
as he was taken in the
3rd Round (#33 overall), but the 34-year-old Norton proved to be an
incredible bargain for the Gang as he was taken in the 14th round (#187
overall), right between Marco Scutaro
and Zack Greinke. However, neither
one is expected to be a keeper (MLB '07: League just returned to
the majors July 16 after being out with an injury; Norton is hitting
.178 with a .588 OPS in just 90 ABs), giving them little value to
the 12th-place Gang.
It's only been a week, but so far
neither League (3 ER, 7 H, 1 BB, 1 HR in 5.0 IP) nor
Norton (.167 BA,
.556 OPS in 18 AB) has done anything to his impress his new teammates.
Meanwhile, Wainwright also has been awful since joining South Boston (3
ER, 3 H, 3 BB, 1 HR in 2.2 IP), but the Gang-bangers don't care how the
righthander fares this season; they're more interested in using him as
a starter next year (MLB '07: 4.36 ERA, 1.51 WHIP overall, but 3.06
ERA, 1.21 WHIP since June 1). This trade could clearly go either
way; at the moment, we'll have to say it's just too
early to call.
Chris Nabholz was the subject of
one of
the
league's most controversial trades on Dec. 12, 1991, when the Austin
Outlaws
southpaw was dealt to the Scranton Sparrows for unspecified "future
considerations."
The cantankerous owners couldn't agree on adequate compensation and
ultimately
the trade was resolved through arbitration, with Scranton getting
Austin's
5th and 15th round picks in 1993. Trades for "future considerations,"
players
to be named later, cash and so on were banned after this trade. Nabholz
now
lives in Pottsville, Pa., where he helps coach the local high school
team
and at baseball camps. Click
Here for past articles.
|